On March 8th, an article titled “Immigrant
Privilege Drives Child Rape Epidemic” was posted on Ann Coulter’s blog. The
blogpost discusses immigration crime rates in America, however approximately
50% of the articles is made up of a list of headline titles involving the rape
of children by immigrants. The audience of this article is clearly geared
towards steady conservatives with no intent to convince people with opposing views,
for the following reasons.
Starting at the top of the post, her first sentence states that we
should be relieved that we do not have “Muslim rapists pouring into our country”,
but infers that we can’t relax because “we have Mexican rapists pouring into
our country.” This inflammatory statement is clearly offensive and not conducive
to welcoming a variety of readers to enjoy this article. The very next sentence
refers to Latin America as being a ‘peasant culture’, and then adds that
Muslims are also ‘peasant culture’. It is important to note that these two
things she equates under the umbrella term ‘peasant cultures’ include the followers
of the second most popular religion in the world, and 21 separate countries
that are commonly referred to as Latin America. Shortly after this, she states
that her statistics don’t even include legal immigrants, adding that she
believes that legal immigrants are even worse than illegal. If I were dissect
every sentence of this article and their racist and ignorant connotations, this
commentary would be longer than her article, so I will stick to these
statements. What does she mean by the term ‘peasant cultures’? Despite the fact
that she has been recorded saying this phrase as early as 2015, I could find no
other source of any other person or reporter using it, and it seems to have no
real definition.
The
only sources she cites within this post is one of her own articles, and a website
called North Carolinians for Immigration Reform and Enforcement, which appears
to be a citizen run advice forum on how to report illegal immigrants and their
employers. One of the most important points of a solid argument is that you mention
the opposing points of views, and discredit them, but she did not do this
either because it wouldn’t matter to the audience she was writing for, or
because she can’t deny the statistics that prove her statements false. This
article from The New York Times discusses how “Contrary to Trump’s Claims,Immigrants Are Less Likely to Commit Crimes”, and cites many studies such as
this, and this. These sources cited by the well reputed paper The New York Times cite real statistics that have been put together by qualified researchers from well known institutions, while Ann Coulter's sole source is as reliable as Wikipedia, since there is no information on who is running the domain, or any sources for it's information.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments?